ARTICLES / Certified Opinion

 

A certified opinion is a formal judgment or conclusion provided by a qualified expert in a specific field, in this case the sports memorabilia industry authentication/evaluation documented in writing and supported by evidence, training, or analysis. While it carries the weight of the expert's authority and credibility, it is not an absolute guarantee but rather a reasonable assessment based on the best available information.

 

Characteristics of a Certified Opinion:

• Professional Expertise: Issued by someone with recognized qualifications, training, and experience in the relevant area.
  
  
• Evidence-Based: Relies on a thorough review of evidence, data, or artifacts.
  
  
• Documented: Comes with an official certificate or statement outlining the basis for the opinion.
  
  
• Subject to Limitations: Acknowledges that the conclusion is an informed judgment and not infallible.
  
  
• Credibility: The value of the opinion depends on the expert’s reputation and adherence to established standards.
  
  

Examples:

• A handwriting expert's written assessment on the authenticity of a signature.
• An appraiser's valuation of an artwork or antique.
• A forensic accountant’s analysis of financial discrepancies.

In essence, a certified opinion is an authoritative, yet qualified statement intended to guide decisions or establish credibility in a given matter.